Brilliant Sales Compensation Plans - Makana Solutions
describe the image

Sales Compensation Blog

 

Sales Compensation Tips and Advice

Current Articles | RSS Feed RSS Feed

Incentives Gone Wrong – What’s Your Story?

Posted by www.makanasolutions.com Admin on Tue, Sep 30, 2008 @ 09:05 AM
  | Submit to Digg digg it |  Add to delicious  delicious |  Submit to StumbleUpon StumbleUpon | Submit to Reddit reddit 

I am very interested in hearing your stories about the unintended consequences of your incentive programs. I think we all have them and we can benefit from sharing them. As the mother of two daughters who have just made it through the teenage years, I believe we are all much better off if we talk to others about the ways they (teenagers or incentive programs) can act out. It gives you perspective, lets you laugh at the absurdity and helps you know what to watch out for.

My Story - Teamwork

So, I'll start. My story happened at an enterprise software company. The company sold expensive software that required expensive service implementations. It was imperative that the company operate as a team between sales, service and engineering. We were constantly making tradeoffs between product features and services, frequently opting to defer features we felt could be ‘managed' by the services team. Services and engineering needed to work together. Similarly, sales needed the services team to help make proposals to clients that were realistic yet within the client's budgets. Teamwork was essential all around.

But it didn't happen. Turns out much of the problem lay in the sales incentive plans. The services team was compensated on margin while the sales team was compensated on software sales. And just to add a nasty twist, the head of engineering was also being compensated on new sales. What happened? The service bids would come in too high (because they wanted the margins) so instead, the sales team got quotes from engineering and gave away the services component. Much friction ensued and I would estimate close to $2M was lost in revenue while customer satisfaction dropped.

Moral of the story: look at the metrics across job roles and make sure your teams are incented to work together.

Do you have a story? I'd love to hear it.

 


 

Tags: 

COMMENTS

Liz, 
 
Thanks for a very informative and valuable webinar yesterday. You spotlighted many of our problems that we are only now beginning to recognize. 
 
 
 
We are a small software company that has been in businss since 1984. We were early adopters of what is now known as SaaS because we discovered early that the department who needed our system did not have the power of the purse string but could expense a monthly 'rental'. Over the years the business model has varied back and forth from an emphasis on License sales to Subscription fees. This was not an immediate problem because the responsibility for sales performance was primarily in the hands of the principals. 
 
 
 
Within the past 12 months we have begun to build a direct sales force and began by hiring a 'Top Gun' Salesperson to head up that program. Thus a 'down and dirty' compensation plan was contrived and the problems began.  
 
 
 
I'm sure our problems are not unique but we know they will grow if not addressed. Addressing them will probably mean some internal reorganization and dealing with some 'legacy' issues. I'm not sure that we are well equipped to take the 'next step' without some outside input. Any suggestions? 
 
 
 
I can be reached at 800-383-1999, ext 228.

posted @ Wednesday, January 14, 2009 2:23 PM by Tim Sudderth, CEO, SureQuest Systems, Inc.


There are a few good "compensation gone wrong" stories in the following article:http://www.salesarchitecture.com/articles/2008/100608.html  
 
The article itself offers an interesting new way to think about plans, they need to consider sales people, the organizations best interest and the clients best interest. All of those need to be in balance to develop the perfect plan.

posted @ Friday, March 13, 2009 11:53 AM by Thereasa Fullmer


Here's another good one...Cisco Resolves Long-standing Field Compensation  
 
IssueNews and Commentary from the Cisco Partner Summit 
Beth Vanni 
 
Thousands of partners are in the room. 3500 partners are participating in the Virtual Summit event. Press and analysts hang on every word from the senior executives, listening for new major investments and innovations. These are the hallmarks of the Cisco Partner Summit, this year based in Boston, one of the oldest and most sophisticated cities in the U.S. Many also revere Cisco’s commitment to channels and partnering among the oldest and most mature in the high tech world. Admittedly, their programs, automation, incentives and partnering commitment from the top-down is legendary. But, then I listened closely to the keynote speech form Keith Goodwin, Cisco’s SVP of Global Channels…… 
 
The Cisco management team announced many channel program enhancements already this week including new services offerings, further extended credit terms to partners, eliminating on-site certification audits,implementing a new limited lifetime warranty on certain products and adding a new 15% rebate for core switching products. Much of these announcements will really help keep partners focused and profitable on core Cisco technologies and will encourage them to continue to invest in training and pre-sales work. But,the announcement that got THE loudest applause from the audience was around Cisco field sales compensation. Something so basic that it’s hard to imagine Cisco still having this issue acting as a barrier to partner field engagement.... 
 
to see the complete article:  
 
http://amazonconsultingblog.wordpress.com/2009/06/03/cisco-resolves-long-standing-field-compensation-issue/#comment-73

posted @ Thursday, June 04, 2009 10:50 AM by Liz Cobb


Post Comment
Name
 *
Email
 *
Website (optional)
Comment
 *

Allowed tags: <a> link, <b> bold, <i> italics

Your email:
 
sales compensation white paper
sales compensation survey
sales commission
sales compensation sample plan
sales compensation blog
 sales compensation data sheet
sales compensation consulting
Add to Technorati Favorites
Directory of Business Blogs
 
Makana is a registered trademark and Makana Motivator is a service mark of Salary.com. 2000-2009 © Salary.com, Inc. All rights reserved.
Protecting Your Privacy     Securing Your Data

Try Makana Motivator sales compensation software risk free Makana Motivator Customer Support Customer Login to Makana Motivator Makana Solutions Sales Compensation Blog Makana Solutions Home Page